Skip to content

Get started with CaptainU

I'm an athlete

See how over 3 million athletes have already used CaptainU to follow their dreams of playing sports in college.

Get started

I'm a college coach

Over 10,000 college coaches currently use CaptainU to find top talent. Search thousands of student-athletes and discover your next recruit.

Get started

Partnerships + events

CaptainU is proud to partner with organizations who share our passion for helping high school athletes achieve their recruiting goals.

Get started

Calling College Coaches

Why Call a College Coach?

Email and text are useful recruiting tools, but a phone call gives you something they can’t: a real conversation.

Talking with a coach helps you learn more about their program while giving them a better sense of who you are: how you communicate, how mature you are, and how serious you are about their school. Those are things a highlight video can’t fully show.

Coaches want to hear from you, not just from your parents or club coach. Taking ownership of your recruiting communication, especially as you move through high school, shows a coach that you’re ready for the independence of college athletics.

Know the Rules Before You Dial

Recruiting communication rules vary by association, division, sport, and grade level, so it helps to understand the basics:

  • NCAA: The NCAA allows coaches to contact recruits through calls, texts, emails and other approved methods, but when that can start depends on sport- and division-specific rules. In many Division I sports, a coach may not be able to reach out to you, or say much, until you reach a certain point in high school.
  • NAIA: The NAIA doesn’t restrict when or how often students and college coaches can communicate. You and the coach set the terms.
  • Junior college and others: Rules differ by association, so check with the program directly.

Here’s the key takeaway: if a coach keeps a call short or says they can’t talk with you yet, it’s often because of the rules, not a lack of interest. Ask politely when they’ll be able to talk, and keep them updated by email in the meantime. For sport-specific details, check the NCAA’s recruiting resources or ask the school’s athletics compliance office.

1. Prepare Before You Call

Don’t Wing It

Before picking up the phone, research the school and have a few notes in front of you. Know:

  • The coach’s name and position (head coach, assistant, recruiting coordinator)
  • Your graduation year and position or event
  • Why you’re interested in the school, both athletically and academically
  • A few things about the program, such as last season’s results, roster needs and style of play
  • Your key athletic and academic information, including your GPA, test scores if you have them, and recent stats or times

You don’t need a script, but having talking points helps you stay calm and confident.

Send an Email First

A short email before you call gives the coach context. Introduce yourself, include a link to your recruiting profile and highlight video, and mention that you’d love to set up a quick call. When the coach sees your name pop up again, it will already feel familiar.

Pick a Good Time

Coaches are busy, especially in season. Try to avoid calling right before practice or on game days. Late morning or early afternoon on a weekday is often a safer bet. If the coach suggests a time, take it.

2. Introduce Yourself

Make the First 30 Seconds Count

Start with who you are and why you’re calling. For example:

“Hi Coach Smith, this is Sarah Johnson. I’m a 2028 midfielder with Wilmington FC, and I’m very interested in your program. I wanted to introduce myself and learn more about your team. Is now a good time to talk for a few minutes?”

Asking whether it’s a good time is a small move that shows respect. Then keep it natural and let the conversation develop from there.

3. If You Get Voicemail

Many first calls end up in voicemail, and that’s okay. Leave a message that’s under 30 seconds and easy to act on:

“Hi Coach Smith, this is Sarah Johnson, a 2028 midfielder with Wilmington FC. I sent you an email this week with my profile and highlight video. I’d love to learn more about your program. My cell number is 555-555-0142. Again, that’s 555-555-0142. Thank you, Coach.”

Say your phone number slowly and repeat it once, just like the example. Then send a quick follow-up email so the coach has everything in writing.

4. Ask Good Questions

Remember: You’re Evaluating the School, Too

Don’t make the whole call about trying to impress the coach. Ask questions such as:

  • What are you looking for in my recruiting class?
  • How do you see my position fitting into the team?
  • What is your team’s training environment like?
  • How do you support athletes academically?
  • What does a typical week look like for your athletes in season?
  • What are the next steps in your recruiting process?

Save detailed questions about scholarships and financial aid for later conversations, once you and the coach have built a relationship. A good conversation should go both ways.

5. Listen More Than You Talk

A Phone Call Is a Conversation

You don’t need to spend 20 minutes listing every award you’ve ever won. The coach can read your profile.

Listen carefully to what the coach says. Right after the call, write down anything important about the program, the recruiting timeline, or the next steps the coach mentioned.

Being a good communicator starts with being a good listener.

6. Follow Up

Finish Strong

Within a day, send a short thank-you message. For example:

“Thank you for taking the time to speak with me today, Coach. I really enjoyed learning more about the program and appreciate the opportunity to connect. I’m looking forward to staying in touch.”

Then follow through on anything you discussed, whether that’s sending updated video, sharing your tournament schedule, or registering for a camp. Doing what you said you’d do is one of the best ways to stand out.

A Note for Parents

It’s natural to want to help, and you can: help your athlete research schools, practice a mock call, and stay nearby for support. But let your athlete do the talking. Coaches are recruiting your son or daughter, and they want to hear directly from the person who will be on their roster.

Your Pre-Call Checklist

  • Research the program
  • Know your athletic and academic information
  • Prepare three to five questions
  • Find a quiet place with good reception
  • Keep your recruiting profile and video link ready
  • Have something to take notes with
  • Make sure the communication is permitted under the recruiting rules for your sport and division

The Bottom Line

Confidence Beats a Perfect Script

Calling a college coach can feel intimidating, especially the first time. Don’t worry about saying everything perfectly. Every call gets easier.

Be prepared. Be respectful. Ask questions. Listen.

And remember, you’re not calling to convince a coach that you’re perfect. You’re starting a conversation to find out whether you’re a good fit for each other.

Ready to start the conversation? Create your CaptainU profile today so college coaches can see your video, stats and academics, and connect with the programs that fit you best.